Psychiatric Bulletin (2002) 26: 319. doi: 10.1192/pb.26.8.319-a
© 2002 The Royal College of Psychiatrists
Psychiatric Bulletin (2002) 26: 319
© 2002 The Royal College of Psychiatrists
Developing Care Pathways. The Toolkit
By Kathryn de Luc
L. Mynors-Wallis, Medical Director
Dorset Healthcare NHS Trust
Abingdon: Radcliffe Medical Press. 2001. 43 pp. £30.00 (sold with
Hand-book, pb). ISBN: 1-85775-499-9
Care pathways have been developed in many areas of medicine. Such pathways
can be a helpful way of ensuring that clinicians implement good practice
guidelines. They can also be helpful as a way of empowering patients with the
knowledge of what treatments they can expect and within what time-frame.
Developing Care Pathways has been written to facilitate the
development of care pathways: explaining what they are and how to go about
producing one.
Unfortunately, in spite of being in two volumes a handbook and a
toolkit what has been produced is a simplistic account of care
pathways, long on the obvious and short on how to overcome any difficulties.
The book was disappointing in two main aspects. First, there was insufficient
material provided as to the evidence that care pathways actually improve the
process of care. It would have been useful to have evidence both for and
against the use of such pathways rather than simply seeing them as a good
thing. Second, it would have been useful to have had much more information
about problems that exist in implementing pathways. For example, how does one
overcome clinician resistance? Is the extra paperwork that will almost
inevitably be involved be justified by the result? Are care pathways completed
accurately by staff? Are deficiencies in care highlighted by care pathways
remedied to bring about improved patient results?
Although this book may be useful for someone who knows nothing about care
pathways as an introduction to the concept, anyone who has had experience of
developing their own care pathway will probably not learn anything new.