Hostname: page-component-7c8c6479df-xxrs7 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-03-28T10:59:10.166Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Substance use disorders and psychological trauma

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  02 January 2018

Shaheen Shora
Affiliation:
Barnet, Enfield and Haringey Mental Health NHS Trust, Chase Farm Hospital, Enfield
Elizabeth Stone
Affiliation:
New House Drug and Alcohol Unit, Shelton Hospital, Shrewsbury
Keron Fletcher
Affiliation:
New House Drug and Alcohol Unit, Shelton Hospital, Shrewsbury SY3 8DN, email: keron.fletcher@sssft.nhs.uk
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Aims and Method

The Impact of Events Scale was administered to 104 in-patients detoxing from alcohol or opiates to determine the prevalence of psychological trauma, the severity of its symptoms and the types of trauma responsible for symptoms.

Results

Out of the 104 in-patients undergoing detoxification, 75 had symptoms of psychological trauma; in 60 patients the symptoms were in the treatable range. Patients with alcohol-dependence were more severely affected. ‘Life events’ traumatised a higher proportion of individuals than ‘traumatic events’.

Clinical Implications

Psychological trauma requiring treatment is commonly found in substance misusers. This is rarely addressed despite the cormorbid disorder running a complicated clinical course. There are conflicting opinions about best practice, but consideration should be given to providing patients with accessible treatments for psychological trauma.

Type
Original papers
Creative Commons
Creative Common License - CCCreative Common License - BY
This is an Open Access article, distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC-BY) license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted re-use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Copyright
Copyright © Royal College of Psychiatrists, 2009

There are strong associations between substance misuse and psychological trauma. According to one US study, 3% of substance misusers in the general population have post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Reference Cottler, Compton, Mager, Spitznagel and Janca1 Rates of PTSD in female substance misusers on in-patient units rise to 42.5% Reference Dansky, Saladin, Brady, Kilpatrick and Resnick2 and to 62% for pregnant women treated in a residential setting. Reference Thompson and Kingree3 In the UK, rates of PTSD on in-patient substance misuse units have been reported at 38.5% for current PTSD and at 51.9% for lifetime PTSD. Reference Reynolds, Mezey, Chapman, Wheeler, Drummond and Baldacchino4 Surveys of adolescent substance misusers report PTSD rates of up to 19.2%. Reference Deykin and Buka5

In civilian populations without PTSD, rates of lifetime substance misuse range from 8.1 to 24.7%, but in those with PTSD the levels rise to 21.6-43.0%. Reference Kessler, Sonnega, Bromet, Hughes and Nelson6-Reference Breslau, Davis, Peterson and Schultz8 Up to 75% of US and UK war veterans with PTSD meet the criteria for alcohol misuse or dependence. Reference Kulka, Schlenger, Fairbank, Hough, Jordan and Marmar9,Reference Fletcher10

Individuals with comorbid substance misuse and PTSD are more likely to have other psychiatric diagnoses, higher rates of psychosocial and physical problems, higher rates of in-patient admissions for substance misuse and higher rates of relapse compared with substance misusers without PTSD. Reference Breslau, Davis, Peterson and Schultz8,Reference Najavits, Gastfriend, Barber, Reif, Muenz and Blaine11

Within the general population, estimates of childhood sexual abuse in women are around 21-22% and in men 7-15%. Reference Kelly, Regan and Burton12,Reference López, Carpintero, Hernàndez, Martín and Fuertes13 However, childhood sexual abuse levels among substance misusers on in-patient detoxification units range from 49 to 67% for women and 12-33% for men. Reference Windle, Windle, Scheidt and Miller14-Reference Stone16

The association between substance misuse and psychological trauma is therefore important, not only because of the frequency of comorbidity and the additional complexity of the presentation, but also because of the more complicated clinical course and poorer prognosis.

This paper presents the results of a survey of 104 individuals with alcohol or opiate dependence who were undergoing a detoxification at New House Drug and Alcohol Unit, Shrewsbury, Shropshire. The survey sought to identify the number of individuals who were currently affected by symptoms of psychological trauma, to assess the severity of any psychological trauma using the Impact of Events Scale (IES), Reference Horowitz, Wilner and Alvarez17,Reference Sundin and Horowitz18 and to identify and describe the sorts of events that patients considered to be responsible for the development of their psychological trauma symptoms. Implications for the management of these individuals are discussed in the light of research findings and the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) guidelines for the management of PTSD. 19

Method

All individuals who participated in this survey had given informed consent. A total of 104 in-patients with alcohol or opiate dependence undergoing detoxification were assessed for current symptoms of psychological trauma using the Impact of Events Scale (IES). This instrument was administered when patients were no longer experiencing any acute symptoms of alcohol or opiate detoxification. The IES grades the severity of 15 characteristic symptoms of psychological trauma that have been experienced in the 7 days before testing. Eight items of avoidance behaviour and seven items related to intrusive memories are measured. The maximum score is 75. Scores over 25 are considered to indicate a level of disorder that requires treatment. The severity of symptoms were rated as subclinical (scores between 0 and 8), mild (9-25), moderate (26-43) and severe (scores over 43) in accordance with the guidelines of Corneil et al Reference Corniel, Beaton, Murphy, Johnson and Pike20 (E. Hutchings, personal communication, 2004). The IES also records the date and nature of the event considered responsible for the symptoms of psychological trauma.

We used the χ2-test for statistical analysis of proportions and the t-test for differences between means.

Results

The prevalence and severity of symptoms of psychological trauma according to type of dependence and gender are summarised in Table 1.

Table 1. Mean IES scores and prevalence data by severitya

Gender
IES trauma score Alcohol dependence n = 73 Opiate dependence n = 26 Dual dependence n = 5 Male n = 74 Female n = 30
Mean IES scores 29.7 19.0 29.4 25.6 30.4
IES scores 0–8 (subclinical) 16 12 1 21 8
IES scores 9–25 (mild) 11 3 1 12 3
IES scores 26–43 (moderate) 26 8 1 26 9
IES scores 44–75 (severe) 20 3 2 15 10

Overall, 75/104 patients had symptoms of psychological trauma: 60 patients had symptoms in the treatable range (IES>25) and 25 scored in the severe range (IES>43).

The number of traumatised patients with alcohol dependence (57/73) was significantly higher than the proportion of traumatised patients with opiate dependence (14/26; χ2 = 5.552, P = 0.018). Similarly, the mean IES score of patients with alcohol dependence was significantly higher than that of patients with opiate dependence (t = 2.367, P = 0.019). There were too few patients with dual dependence to draw any conclusions.

There were no significant differences between the IES scores of males and females. However, only 15/74 (20%) male patients scored in the severe range on the IES compared with 10/30 (33%) females, suggesting that there is a non-significant trend for females to experience severe symptoms of psychological trauma compared with males (χ2 = 1.995, P =0.16).

Data showing the types of events considered responsible for symptoms of psychological trauma in 75 affected patients are summarised in Table 2.

Table 2. Life events and traumatic events that patients associated with psychological trauma

Event Symptomatic patients, n
Life event
   Death (e.g. loss of parents/siblings/children) 23
   Divorce or separation (e.g. voluntary or enforced separation from wife/husband/children) 15
   Adult abuse (e.g. bullying at work, bullying within family, emotional abuse by partner, domestic violence) 4
Traumatic event
   Child abuse (e.g. childhood abuse (physical/sexual/emotional) perpetrated by parent or other family member) 19
   Violent assault (e.g. held hostage, road traffic accident, industrial accident, rape, surgical complications) 9
   Saw trauma (e.g. witnessed man shot in head, found hanging body, army service in Korea, saw boyfriend murdered, saw suicide of father) 5

‘Life events’ were responsible for symptoms in 56% of individuals. The mean IES score for life events was very close to that for ‘traumatic events’ (36.8 and 37.9 respectively).

Traumatic events occurred in 44% of the affected group. A significantly greater proportion of females in this group experienced severe symptoms (IES>43; n =7/22 females, n =5/53 males; χ2 =5.796, P =0.02) and were significantly more likely to report childhood abuse (n = 10/22 females, n =9/53 males; χ2 =6.663, P =0.01).

Discussion

The prevalence of symptoms of psychological trauma in patients on a detoxification unit was surprisingly high. The results of this survey suggest that over half of the patients interviewed (58%) had symptoms in the range requiring treatment and almost a quarter (24%) had IES scores that were severe. It is not possible to make a diagnosis of PTSD from an IES score. However, these findings support the US and UK data. Reference Dansky, Saladin, Brady, Kilpatrick and Resnick2,Reference Reynolds, Mezey, Chapman, Wheeler, Drummond and Baldacchino4

Patients with alcohol dependence were significantly more likely than patients with opiate dependence to report symptoms of psychological trauma and their greater severity. This may be due to the fact that the in-patient unit only admits people with complex, severe alcohol dependence, whereas, in contrast, access for opiate users is enhanced in order to meet current treatment targets. Life events were associated with symptoms in more individuals than traumatic events and, unexpectedly in our view, resulted in IES scores of equal severity. In this sample, the nature of the event itself appears to give little indication of the traumatising effect it may have. Life events would not be regarded within ICD-10 or DSM-IV as sufficiently extreme or catastrophic to induce PTSD. However, our observation is similar to that of Mol et al Reference Mol, Arntz, Metsemakers, Dinant, Vilters-van Montfort and Knottnerus21 and highlights a potential diagnostic anomaly in which all the symptoms of psychological trauma or PTSD may be present, but the nature of the traumatic incident eliminates a diagnosis. This inconsistency may be addressed in DSM-V. Reference Rosen, Spitzer and McHugh22 A greater proportion of female patients reported IES scores in the severe range resulting from a traumatic event, and they were also more likely to report childhood abuse than male patients. These findings are consistent with those from previous studies. Reference Reynolds, Mezey, Chapman, Wheeler, Drummond and Baldacchino4,Reference Najavits, Gastfriend, Barber, Reif, Muenz and Blaine11,Reference Stone16,Reference Triffleman, Marmar, Delucchi and Ronfeldt23

This survey demonstrates the value of routinely assessing substance misusers for symptoms of psychological trauma. Clinical and epidemiological studies confirm that comorbidity between PTSD and substance use disorders is common and that such patients tend to be more severely affected and more refractory to treatment than those having either disorder alone. Reference Najavits, Gastfriend, Barber, Reif, Muenz and Blaine11,Reference Ouimette, Brown and Najavits24

Implications for clinical practice

The strong relationship between alcohol problems in particular and psychological trauma has implications for patient management. Existing research suggests that this client group may benefit from the following range of measures: 25

  1. referral to specialist PTSD /mental health services

  2. simultaneous treatment of both conditions

  3. combined programme of pharmacotherapy and psychotherapy

  4. patient education

  5. learning coping and relapse preventions skills

  6. cognitive-behavioural therapy.

The NICE guidelines for the management of PTSD recommend tackling substance misuse difficulties before offering trauma-focused interventions (although this relates to simple cases of PTSD - the guidelines for the management of ‘complex PTSD’ have yet to be published). 19 However, this contrasts with advice from Lisa Najavits’ ‘Seeking Safety’ programme and from Alcohol Concern, both of which recommend managing the two disorders simultaneously. Given the limited availability of specialist treatments for alcohol problems and PTSD even when they exist as separate disorders, in practice neither of these forms of advice is likely to be followed where there is comorbidity. Waiting times for trauma-focused interventions frequently prove too long for individuals with addictive disorders for whom the use of substances may be, in part, a way of coping with the symptoms of trauma. This failure needs to be addressed, especially for women, who are more likely to be severely traumatised, so that trauma services can be made accessible for those patients who are substantially vulnerable and severely affected.

Conclusions

The common and complex relationship between substance misuse and psychological trauma demonstrates the pressing need to screen for, and treat, both conditions. Despite the frequency with which individuals with comorbid disorder present for treatment, no systematic treatment approach of proven efficacy has been developed for this vulnerable patient group in the UK. Comorbid substance dependence and psychological trauma receives considerable attention in research, but very little emphasis in routine clinical practice.

Declaration of interest

None.

References

1 Cottler, LB, Compton, WM III, Mager, D, Spitznagel, EL, Janca, A. Posttraumatic stress disorder among substance users from the general population. Am J Psychiatry 1992; 149: 664–70.Google ScholarPubMed
2 Dansky, BS, Saladin, ME, Brady, KT, Kilpatrick, DG, Resnick, HS. Prevalence of victimization and posttraumatic stress disorder among women with substance use disorders: comparison of telephone and in-person assessment samples. Int J Addict 1995; 30: 1079–99.Google ScholarPubMed
3 Thompson, MP, Kingree, JB. The frequency and impact of violent trauma among pregnant substance abusers. Addict Behav 1998; 23: 257–62.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
4 Reynolds, M, Mezey, G, Chapman, M, Wheeler, M, Drummond, C, Baldacchino, A. Co-morbid post-traumatic stress disorder in a substance misusing clinical population. Drug Alcohol Depend 2005; 77: 251–8.Google Scholar
5 Deykin, EY, Buka, SL. Prevalence and risk factors for posttraumatic stress disorder among chemically dependent adolescents. Am J Psychiatry 1997; 154: 752–7.Google Scholar
6 Kessler, RC, Sonnega, A, Bromet, E, Hughes, M, Nelson, CB. Posttraumatic stress disorder in the National Comorbidity Survey. Arch Gen Psychiatry 1995; 52: 1048–60.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
7 Breslau, N, Davis, GC, Andreski, P, Peterson, E. Traumatic events and posttraumatic stress disorder in an urban population of young adults. Arch Gen Psychiatry 1991; 48: 216–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
8 Breslau, N, Davis, GC, Peterson, EL, Schultz, L. Psychiatric sequelae of posttraumatic stress disorder in women. Arch Gen Psychiatry 1997; 54: 81–7.Google ScholarPubMed
9 Kulka, RA, Schlenger, WE, Fairbank, JA, Hough, RL, Jordan, BK, Marmar, CR, et al. Trauma and the Vietnam War Generation: Report of Findings from the National Vietnam Veterans Readjustment Study. Brunner/ Mazel, 1990.Google Scholar
10 Fletcher, KD. Combat stress (the Ex-Servicemen's Mental Welfare Society) and war veterans. In War and Health: Lessons from the Gulf War: 89112. Wiley, 2007.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
11 Najavits, LM, Gastfriend, DR, Barber, JP, Reif, S, Muenz, LR, Blaine, J, et al. Cocaine dependence with and without PTSD among subjects in the National Institute on Drug Abuse Collaborative Cocaine Treatment Study. Am J Psychiatry 1998; 155: 214–9.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
12 Kelly, L, Regan, L, Burton, S. An Exploratory Study of the Prevalence of Sexual Abuse in a Sample of 16–21 Year Olds. University of North London, 1991.Google Scholar
13 López, F, Carpintero, E, Hernàndez, A, Martín, MJ, Fuertes, A. Prevalence and sequelae of childhood sexual abuse in Spain. Child Abuse Negl 1995; 19: 1039–50.Google ScholarPubMed
14 Windle, M, Windle, R, Scheidt, DM, Miller, GB. Physical and sexual abuse and associated mental disorders among alcoholic in-patients. Am J Psychiatry 1995; 152: 1322–8.Google Scholar
15 Moncrieff, J, Drummond, DC, Candy, B, Checinski, K, Farmer, R. Sexual abuse in people with alcohol problems. A study of the prevalence of sexual abuse and its relationship to drinking behaviour. Br J Psychiatry 1996; 169: 355–60.Google Scholar
16 Stone, EA. Childhood Sexual Abuse and Substance Misuse (MSc dissertation). Imperial College London, 2005.Google Scholar
17 Horowitz, M, Wilner, N, Alvarez, W. Impact of Events Scale. Psychosom Med 1979; 41: 209–18.Google Scholar
18 Sundin, EC, Horowitz, ML. Horowitz's Impact of Event Scale evaluation of 20 years of use. Psychosom Med 2003; 65: 870–6.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
19 National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence. Management of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder in Adults in Primary, Secondary and Community Care. Clinical guideline 26. NICE, 2005.Google Scholar
20 Corniel, W, Beaton, R, Murphy, S, Johnson, C, Pike, K. Exposure to traumatic incidents and prevalence of post-traumatic stress symptomatology in urban firefighters in two countries. J Occup Health Psychol 1999; 4, 131–41.Google Scholar
21 Mol, SSL, Arntz, A, Metsemakers, JFM, Dinant, G-J, Vilters-van Montfort, PAP, Knottnerus, JA. Symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder after non-traumatic events: evidence from an open population study. Br J Psychiatry 2005; 186: 494–9.Google Scholar
22 Rosen, GM, Spitzer, RL, McHugh, PR. Problems with the post-traumatic stress disorder diagnosis and its future in DSM–V. Br J Psychiatry 2008; 192: 34.Google Scholar
23 Triffleman, EG, Marmar, CR, Delucchi, KL, Ronfeldt, H. Childhood trauma and PTSD in substance abuse in-patients. J Nerv Ment Dis 1995; 183: 172–6.Google Scholar
24 Ouimette, PC, Brown, KT, Najavits, LM. Course and treatment of patients with both substance use and posttraumatic stress disorders. Addict Behav 1998; 23: 785–95.Google Scholar
25 Alcohol Concern. Mental Health and Alcohol Misuse Project, Factsheet 6: Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder and Alcohol. Alcohol Concern, 2004 (http://www.alcoholconcern.org.uk/files/20040709_145809_ptsd%20factsheet.pdf).Google Scholar
Figure 0

Table 1. Mean IES scores and prevalence data by severitya

Figure 1

Table 2. Life events and traumatic events that patients associated with psychological trauma

Submit a response

eLetters

No eLetters have been published for this article.