Hostname: page-component-7c8c6479df-7qhmt Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-03-28T12:28:37.154Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Floods in 2007 and older adult services: lessons learnt

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  02 January 2018

Joseph Hayes
Affiliation:
West Oxfordshire Community Mental Health Team for Older Adults
Julian Mason
Affiliation:
Prospect Park Hospital, Honey End Land, RG30 4EJ, email: jules.mason@berkshire.nhs.uk
Fay Brown
Affiliation:
West Oxfordshire Community Mental Health Team for Older Adults
Rebecca Mather
Affiliation:
West Oxfordshire Community Mental Health Team for Older Adults
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Aims and Method

To review the clinical and managerial impact of flooding on a community mental health team (CMHT) for older adults by prospectively recording all flooding related events met by the CMHT.

Results

Of 348 individuals known to the CMHT, 87 lived in flood affected areas. In nine patients symptoms deteriorated. There were two new referrals as a direct consequence of the flooding. Flood effects can be grouped into: new mental illness, management problems, CMHT workload, and secondary benefits.

Clinical Implications

The immediate and delayed problems caused by flooding to the elderly with mental illness and dementia include unmasking cognitive impairment and provoking exacerbations in depressive and anxiety disorders. Personal evacuation plans should be used when moving individuals with marked cognitive impairment to avoid difficulties with identification. Overcrowding of care homes used to temporarily accommodate additional residents can contribute to behavioural changes and psychological symptoms in those with pre-existing dementia.

Type
Original papers
Creative Commons
Creative Common License - CCCreative Common License - BY
This is an Open Access article, distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC-BY) license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted re-use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Copyright
Copyright © Royal College of Psychiatrists, 2009

It is well recognised that flooding has negative effects on mental health, particularly in people with pre-existing mental illness. Reference Ahern, Kovats, Wilkinson, Few and Matthies1-Reference Oriol and Nordboe3 In this report we discuss the problems encountered by a community mental health team (CMHT) for older adults in West Oxfordshire when the population they serve suffered significant floods.

In July 2007, the heaviest rainfall for 60 years caused immediate flooding. This was followed by swelling of the rivers which then overran pre-existing flood defences. Over 200 elderly people were led to safety from nursing homes and a smaller number from private properties. An unknown number were displaced at very short notice because water damage rendered their properties uninhabitable. 4

Four main factors, relevant to the Oxfordshire floods, are recognised to cause psychological disturbance: immediate threat to life, displacement, damage to property and increased social isolation. Reference Liu, Tan, Zhou, Li, Yang and Wang5 Worldwide, this list would also include bereavement, destruction of whole communities and water-borne disease due to loss of a clean water supply. Reference Ahern, Kovats, Wilkinson, Few and Matthies1

In this brief report we aim to describe the problems encountered by the CMHT following local floods and review what lessons can be learnt, with reference to the relevant studies.

Method

During the floods and in their aftermath the impact on patients and CMHT operations were discussed at several sequential multidisciplinary team meetings and the findings were recorded in the minutes.

Results

The experiences of the team are summarised below. They can be grouped into recognition of new mental illness, management problems, the impact on CMHT workload, and cases where there was a benefit from the flooding.

Impact of flood on patients known to CMHT and those newly referred

Of 348 individuals known to the CMHT at the time of the flood, 87 (36 male and 51 female; Table 1) lived in ‘flood affected’ areas where significant flood waters reached at least as far as their residence. 4 From county council data, 24 were in at least ‘moderate danger’ for their personal safety; 4 7 had to be evacuated from their homes and 6 from nursing homes; 8 patients suffered significant flood damage to their property.

Table 1. Details of 87 patients who lived in flood affected areas

Patients, n Deterioration in mental health after flood, n
Diagnosis
   Mixed dementia 24 3
   Alzheimer's disease 22 0
   Vascular dementia 8 0
   Depression 23 4
   Depression/anxiety 3 1
   Schizophrenia 2 0
   Mild cognitive impairment 4 0
   Paranoid personality disorder 1 1
Difficulty as consequence of flood
   Evacuated from nursing home 6 1
   ‘Moderate danger’ to personal safety1 24 5
   Evacuated from private residence 7 4
   Damage to property 8 6

Apart from the impact on patients already known to the CMHT, two new individuals were referred as a direct consequence of the flooding.

Emergence of new clinical symptoms

Overall, 11 clinical problems were triggered by the floods (Table 2), in ten females and one male, age range 73-90 years (mean 82). The delay in presentation of the symptoms ranged from immediate to 9 months.

Table 2. Flood induced difficulties and the clinical problems triggered in 11 individuals

Pre-flood diagnosis Clinical problem triggered by flood Delay from flood to presentation Flood damage Social isolation Personal safety threat Displacement
Paranoid personality disorder Agitated depression, preoccupation with recent flood and continuing perceived risk 2 months Nil Lived alone with loss of recreational and social outlets as most of village flooded No No
Chronic mixed anxiety and depression Acute deterioration in symptoms 1 week Yes Lived alone Moderate danger Yes (communal emergency accommodation in public building)
No mental illness Depressive episode 9 months Yes Lived alone Moderate danger Yes (lived in holiday accommodation for over 12 months)
Recurrent depression Flashbacks to previous evacuation experiences 1 month Yes No Moderate danger Yes
Recurrent depression Acute deterioration in symptoms 1 week Nil Lived alone Moderate danger No
Recurrent depression Acute deterioration in symptoms 2 weeks Yes Lived alone Moderate danger No
Recurrent depression Acute deterioration in symptoms 1 week Yes No No No
Recurrent depression Chronic deterioration in symptoms while waiting for damage to be repaired 9 months Yes No No No
Mixed dementia Depressive symptoms and behavioural problems requiring admission 3 months Yes Lived alone Moderate danger Yes (moved three times as subsequent accommodation flooded after each move)
Moderate mixed dementia (undiagnosed before flood) Standing in flood water not knowing how to respond appropriately Immediate Yes Lived alone Serious danger, no understanding of threat Yes (in new temporary accommodation cognitive difficulties immediately apparent)
Mixed dementia and psychotic depression Yes (moved into a temporary nursing home) Worsening of psychotic symptoms 2 months No No Moderate danger

It became obvious for one person during a rescue and subsequent care in new accommodation that they had a previously undiagnosed moderated mixed dementia. They had had no noticeable problems until they were found standing waist deep in flood water, unable to react appropriately. From the records, and results of appropriate investigations, there was no evidence to suggest that the cognitive decline had been caused by hypothermia or near drowning. One person with dementia developed problems with behavioural difficulties and depression requiring admission. This followed three moves to escape flooding. A third person with dementia suffered worsening of psychotic symptoms in response to displacement and relative overcrowding in a temporary nursing home. Five people with depression, one person with mixed depression and anxiety, and one with paranoid personality disorder suffered from new depressive symptoms, with the flood being the only recognisable trigger. Only one person was diagnosed with depression without a previous psychiatric history - symptoms emerged after 9 months of living in temporary accommodation waiting for repairs to the flooded property.

Although no cases of post-traumatic stress disorder due to these floods were noted, one person's depression worsened due to recurrence of flashbacks from childhood traumatic evacuation experiences.

Management difficulties in individuals with displaced dementia

The temporary closure of three nursing homes caused overcrowding in those that had to accommodate the displaced people. Some displaced elderly people had to be moved three times because the nursing home they were moved to flooded shortly after they arrived. Staff in a nursing home that had to accommodate extra residents at short notice commented on worsening behaviour in people with dementia due to the overcrowding. This was most noticeable in the communal areas that had to cater for so many more people. Six of the CMHT's patients were evacuated from nursing homes; in one of those patients, symptoms deteriorated markedly.

The inability of people with dementia to remember their full names and identify their own property and medication was an important issue to address for their successful evacuation from a flooded nursing home to new accommodation. Care staff from the nursing home, familiar with their clients, tended to overestimate their ability to remember their names. At each stage of evacuation - leaving the flooded building, boarding transport, staying in a holding area and eventually arriving in new accommodation - great care had to be taken by the professionals to identify each individual correctly as they moved from the care of one team to the next.

Impact on work of CMHT staff

The collapse of one bridge due to greatly increased volume of water affected the journey times for domiciliary visits to certain villages. For 2 days most such visits were cancelled without any noticeable consequences.

The social worker allocated to the team was co-opted to the emergency displacement committee and had to supervise the safe transfer of the elderly people from nursing homes.

Benefit from displacement

Two people with dementia had been living in wholly inadequate properties before the floods. They had persistently refused to move, despite the best attempts of family and professionals to persuade them to move to more suitable accommodation. The flooding precipitated their move to nursing homes. They settled well in their new surroundings and their mental and physical health subsequently improved.

Discussion

There are different forms of flooding. Reference Ahern, Kovats, Wilkinson, Few and Matthies1-Reference Liu, Tan, Zhou, Li, Yang and Wang5 The most severe involve flash flooding and landslides and are most commonly associated with post-traumatic stress disorder in survivors. Reference Verger, Rotily, Hunault, Brenot, Baruffol and Bard6 The psychological impact of these types of floods is comparable to that of earthquakes, volcanoes and tsunamis. Reference Ahern, Kovats, Wilkinson, Few and Matthies1,Reference Phifer2,Reference Liu, Tan, Zhou, Li, Yang and Wang5-Reference Phifer, Kaniasty and Norris7 The type of flooding that affected Oxfordshire is referred to as ‘water soaking’ and triggers quite a different set of problems with delayed psychological symptoms because of damage to property, social isolation and displacement of individuals. Reference Bennett8-Reference Tunstall, Tapsell, Green, Floyd and George10

The risk of individuals suffering from anxiety or depressive symptoms following an episode of flooding is greatly increased by pre-existing symptoms of depression, living alone and having limited social networks. Reference Ginexi, Weihs, Simmens and Hoyt11 Reports have described delayed depressive and anxiety symptoms being triggered in response to later heavy rain or rising water levels. Reference Messner12 Conversely, a study from Colorado, USA, has shown that the elderly who are psychologically healthy may be more resilient when confronted with flooding for a second or third time. This may be caused by an inoculation effect from previous experiences producing psychological resistance to fresh floods. Reference Ferraro13

Displacement has been well recognised as a trigger for psychological symptoms. Reference Fullilove14 The longer someone has lived in a particular place as well as their age are risk factors for developing symptoms, most noticeably anxiety and depression, as a result of displacement. Reference Phifer, Kaniasty and Norris7

Following floods in Brisbane, Australia, there was evidence that elderly people may develop depression as a result of social isolation caused by flooding even though they are personally safe and have not suffered any damage to property. Reference Price15 The loss of community spirit as a direct consequence of flooding has recognisable effects on the mental state of survivors. 16

Damage to property is frequently underappreciated by the public as a cause of distress. Instead, the media and the public focus on the threat to life and displacement of populations. Common foci of frustration following a flood are the loss of irreplaceable emotional items, the cost of repairs to someone's home, and the delay before homes become habitable again. The level of symptoms and the reported stress and anxiety correlate with the cost of the damage and the sense of loss. 16 Women have been found to be more affected by such material losses as they have greater emotional investment in the home and feel a greater responsibility to restore the household to normal. Reference Tunstall9,Reference Tunstall, Tapsell, Green, Floyd and George10

Although not observed among the problems confronting the CMHT, deterioration in physical health has been noted among elderly victims of flooding that is not explained by injury or infectious disease. Reference Phifer, Kaniasty and Norris7 The Flood Hazard Research Centre survey reported that the experience of flooding as a traumatic event is more commonly observed in females and those in poor physical health. Reference Tunstall9,Reference Tunstall, Tapsell, Green, Floyd and George10

Rotherham Primary Care Trust stressed the importance of personal evacuation plans for residents of nursing homes. 17 This should include the provision of photographic identification that would accompany any person with cognitive impairment who, during a crisis, could have difficulty identifying themselves to new professionals.

Conclusions

Our brief report highlights that CMHTs should be alert to the impact of flooding on the elderly with mental illness and dementia - particularly in the days and weeks after the water levels have receded but the repairs to the flood damage are awaited. It is important to be on the lookout for undiagnosed dementia and exacerbations in depressive and anxiety disorders that may appear after several months. Our experience is consistent with previous reports that women are more likely to be negatively affected by the consequences of flooding.

The Environment Agency predicts that the risk of flooding has increased due to changes in weather patterns. It estimates that there are 1028 care homes in the UK that are at risk from flooding. Reference Sayers, Panzeri, Ohl, Segura-Dominguez, Benwell and Deakin18 Special provision through personal evacuation plans should be made to correctly identify people with marked cognitive impairment when they need to be moved at very short notice. Overcrowding of care homes used to temporarily accommodate additional residents can contribute to behavioural difficulties and psychological symptoms in those with pre-existing dementia.

Finally, we must emphasise that we have only discussed here those factors that came to the attention of the CMHT - many elderly people suffer in silence or are managed solely by general practitioners.

References

1 Ahern, M, Kovats, RS, Wilkinson, P, Few, R, Matthies, F. Global health impacts of floods: epidemiologic evidence. Epidemiol Rev 2005; 27: 3646.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
2 Phifer, JF. Psychological distress and somatic symptoms after natural disaster: differential vulnerability among older adults. Psychol Aging 1990; 5: 412–20.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
3 Oriol, W. The nature of disasters and response to them. In Psycho-Social Issues for Older Adults in Disasters (ed Nordboe, D): 412. Centre for Mental Health Services, 2000.Google Scholar
4 West Oxfordshire County Council. Parish/Town Flood Reports–Flood Reviews. West Oxfordshire District Council, 2008 (http://www.westoxon.gov.uk/environmnet/floodreviews.cfm).Google Scholar
5 Liu, A, Tan, H, Zhou, J, Li, S, Yang, T, Wang, J, et al. An epidemiologic study of posttraumatic stress disorder in flood victims in Hunan, China. Can J Psychiatry 2006; 51: 350–4.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
6 Verger, P, Rotily, M, Hunault, C, Brenot, J, Baruffol, E, Bard, D. Assessment of exposure to a flood disaster in a mental health study. J Expo Anal Environ Epidem 2003; 13: 436–42.Google Scholar
7 Phifer, JF, Kaniasty, KZ, Norris, FH. The impact of natural disaster on the health of older adults: a multiwave prospective study. J Health Soc Behav 1988; 29: 6578.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
8 Bennett, G. Bristol floods. Controlled survey of effects on health of local community disaster. BMJ 1970; 3: 454–8.Google Scholar
9 Tunstall, S. Vulnerability and Flooding: A Re-analysis of FHRC Data. Country Report for England and Wales. Floodsite, 2007.Google Scholar
10 Tunstall, S, Tapsell, S, Green, C, Floyd, P, George, C. The health effects of flooding: social research. J Water Health 2006; 4:365–80.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
11 Ginexi, EM, Weihs, K, Simmens, SJ, Hoyt, DR. Natural disaster and depression: a prospective investigation of reactions to the 1993 Midwest floods. Am J Community Psychol 2000; 28: 495518.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
12 Messner, F. Flood Damage, Vulnerability and Risk Perception–Challenges for Flood Damage Research. Floodsite, 2006.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
13 Ferraro, FR. Psychological resilience in older adults following the 1997 flood. Clin Gerontologist 2003; 26: 139–43.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
14 Fullilove, MD. Psychiatric implications of displacement: contributions from the psychology of place. Am J Psychiatry 1996; 153: 1516–23.Google ScholarPubMed
15 Price, J. Some age related effects of the 1974 Brisbane floods. Aust N Z J Psychiatry 1978; 12: 55–8.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
16 The Scottish Government. Household Survey in Exploring the Social Impacts of Flood Risk and Flooding in Scotland, Chapter 4. The Scottish Government, 2007.Google Scholar
17 Rotherham Primary Care Trust. Flood Crisis, June 2007 Debrief Report V2. Rotherham Primary Care Trust, 2007.Google Scholar
18 Sayers, P, Panzeri, M, Ohl, C, Segura-Dominguez, S, Benwell, D, Deakin, R, et al. National flood risk assessment for England and Wales inforesight. In Flood and Coastal Defence Project Synthesis Report. Environment Agency, Department of Trade and Industry, 2003.Google Scholar
Figure 0

Table 1. Details of 87 patients who lived in flood affected areas

Figure 1

Table 2. Flood induced difficulties and the clinical problems triggered in 11 individuals

Submit a response

eLetters

No eLetters have been published for this article.